Custom Home vs. Spec Home in Cache Valley

The short answer

A spec home is built before there's a buyer, using the builder's plan and finish choices, and then sold. A custom home is designed and built for a specific owner, often on land they already have. A spec home gets you into a new house sooner with fewer decisions. A custom home takes more time and more decisions, and gets you a house built around how you actually live.

Both are new construction, and both can be well built. The difference is who makes the choices, and when.

What is a spec home?

"Spec" is short for speculative. The builder picks a lot, picks a plan, chooses the finishes and starts building on the expectation that someone will buy it. In Cache Valley, spec homes usually show up in newer subdivisions, sometimes finished and sometimes partway through construction.

If you find one early in the build, the builder may let you pick some finishes, like paint colors, flooring or cabinet hardware. The floor plan, the lot and anything already built are set.

What is a custom home?

A custom home starts with you. You choose the lot, or build on land you already own. The layout is designed around your family, and you choose the finishes. The builder's job is to turn those decisions into a house that's built right for the site and the climate.

You'll also hear "semi-custom," which usually means choosing from a builder's set of plans and then modifying them. It sits between the two.

Custom vs. spec, side by side

Spec homeCustom home
Who picks the planThe builderYou, with your builder and designer
The lotChosen by the builder, often in a subdivisionYour choice, including land you already own
FinishesMostly chosen by the builderChosen by you, usually with allowances in the contract
Time to move inSooner, especially if it's nearly doneLonger: design, permits and the full build
Decisions you makeA fewA lot
FitBuilt for a typical buyerBuilt for your family, your lot and your plans

When a spec home makes sense

  • You need to move soon and can't wait out a full design and build.
  • A subdivision location works for you.
  • The floor plan is close to what you'd have drawn anyway.
  • You'd rather not make hundreds of decisions.

When a custom home makes sense

This is where Cache Valley's variety comes in. The valley has east bench lots with views of the Bear River Range, acreage in the north end of the valley around Richmond and Lewiston, and infill lots in older Logan neighborhoods. A spec plan designed for a flat subdivision lot rarely fits any of those. Custom makes sense when:

  • You already have the land, or you found the lot first.
  • You need something the market doesn't offer, like a main-floor suite for a parent, a zero-step entry, or a shop.
  • You want a say in how the house handles our winters: where the mudroom goes, how the entry is covered, what the walls are built with.
  • You plan to stay a long time and want the house to fit for all of it.
Custom home with lap siding, stone wainscot and a timber-framed entry built by Bergeson Construction in Cache Valley, Utah
A Bergeson custom home with lap siding, a stone wainscot and a timber-framed entry.

What building custom actually takes

Custom takes longer, and most of the extra time is up front. In our experience it takes two to three months of planning, design, engineering and permitting before we ever pour a foundation, which is why we recommend starting early if you want to build in spring. We break that down in how to time your custom home build in Cache Valley, and walk through every phase in the actual timeline of building a Cache Valley home.

You'll also make a lot of decisions, some of them earlier than you'd expect. Shower valves, for example, are brand-specific and go in the wall at rough-in, long before the fixtures arrive. We wrote about that common plumbing mistake so you can avoid it.

How we build custom at Bergeson

We've built custom homes across Cache Valley since 1979. We've worked with architects, designers, draftsmen and homeowners who bring us sketches on a napkin, and we'll help you figure out whether you need an architect at all. If you don't, we can design it with you.

If you don't have land yet, we can help you evaluate a lot before you buy it. Then our own crew builds it, and every home carries a 1-year warranty on workmanship and materials. See more on our custom home builder page.

Weighing custom against what's on the market? We're happy to talk through your lot, your plans and your timeline before you commit to anything.

Start a Conversation

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a spec home cheaper than a custom home?

Often, though not always. Spec builders choose the plan, lot and finishes themselves and may build several homes at once, which can keep costs down. A custom home's cost depends on your lot, your plan and your selections, so the only reliable comparison is real numbers for your project.

Can I customize a spec home?

Sometimes, a little. If you buy a spec home early in construction, the builder may let you choose some finishes. The floor plan, the lot and anything already built usually can't change.

How long does it take to build a custom home in Cache Valley?

It depends on the size, the design and the season. Planning, design, engineering and permitting typically take two to three months before the foundation is poured, and then the build itself follows. Starting early helps you avoid running into a Cache Valley winter.

Previous
Previous

Why Build a Custom Home in Cache Valley?

Next
Next

General Contractor vs. Home Builder: Which Do You Need in Cache Valley?